Residents crowded into stores Thursday to stock up on supplies, while hotels reported cancellations of trips to Bermuda, which is popular with tourists for its pink sand beaches and with businesspeople as an offshore financial haven.
Leslie, a Category 1 hurricane, was forecast to remain stationary through the night about 430 miles south-southeast of the British enclave. It had sustained winds of 75 mph early Friday.
The U.S. National Hurricane Center said Leslie was expected to intensify Friday and begin to drift northward. Its center was forecast to pass to the east of Bermuda on Sunday morning, possibly as a Category 2 hurricane with winds of nearly 105 mph.
South shore beaches were closed Thursday afternoon as the approaching storm whipped up surf, and residents stocked up on food, propane, tarp, flashlights and water.
"It's great to see people are not waiting until the last minute. We only have three empty shopping carts left at the moment," said Henry Durham, the manager at Gorham's hardware store.
Some people weren't very worried, because Bermuda enforces strict building codes to withstand rough weather. Homes must have walls at least eight inches thick and be able to withstand 150 mph wind gusts. Many power and phone lines are underground.
"The landlord assures me we have a very sturdy roof," said Toby Crawford, a British software developer who moved to Bermuda from London a year ago with his wife, Michelle. "I'm looking forward to it, having not experienced one before."
Michelle Crawford said the couple was prepared to combat boredom being cooped up in their apartment in Pembroke, near the capital of Hamilton.
"I have to admit, we've opted for the alcohol route, as well. We've heard that people have hurricane parties, but so far Toby and I are just planning to hole up at our house with books, board games and wine," she said.
National Security Minister Wayne Perinchief urged all residents to complete their storm preparations by Friday, when the territory's schools would be closed.
Swells from Leslie were affecting Bermuda, the U.S. East Coast, the northern Leeward Islands, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. The swells could cause life-threatening surf and rip currents, the hurricane center said.
Out in the Atlantic, Hurricane Michael weakened from a Category 3 storm to a Category 2, with maximum sustained winds of 105 mph by late Thursday. Earlier in the day, it had become the first Category 3 of the Atlantic hurricane season.
Michael was moving northward at 5 mph over the open ocean and wasn't a threat to land. It was about 930 miles west-southwest of the Azores.
© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.